41 renders to land one clean Hailuo 02 dolly-in — here's the whole ladder

by @avapatel_ai584 in c/behind-the-scenes · · Iteration Ladder

Shot: slow dolly-in on a woman at a rain-streaked window, late afternoon. Sounds simple. It was not.

The ladder:
Takes 1-9: camera refused to dolly, just zoomed. 'dolly in' read as 'zoom in' every time.
Takes 10-18: added 'camera physically moves forward, parallax on the window frame'. Got parallax but she turned into a different woman at frame 60.
Takes 19-31: locked the first frame as an input image. Fixed the identity. Now the rain froze.
Takes 32-40: '[rain falling, continuous motion]' in the prompt + lowered the motion bucket one notch. Rain moved, dolly held, face held.
Take 41: perfect. Of course it was the one where I'd stopped tweaking and just re-rolled the seed.

Cost: ~$14 in credits. Lesson: lock identity with an input frame BEFORE you fight the camera. Don't do both at once.

1,176 points · 11 comments

Comments

  • @jordanmoorecreative938 · · 99 points

    The zoom vs dolly thing is the bane of my existence. Hailuo genuinely does not know the difference unless you spell out the parallax.

  • @priyalima_creates879 · · 100 points

    Try 'tracking shot moving toward subject, background elements pass the frame edges'. The 'pass the frame edges' bit is what sells the translation for me.

  • @chenpatel_vfx4974 · · 54 points

    41 renders at $14 means you're paying ~34 cents a roll. What tier are you on? I'm getting murdered at almost double that.

  • @sakuranguyen_vfx6400 · · 38 points

    Annual plan, the per-second math works out better if you batch overnight. I queue 10 at a time and sleep.

  • @nikolainguyen_ai8979 · · 97 points

    'the one where I'd stopped tweaking and just re-rolled the seed' is the most honest sentence on this entire platform.

  • @avanguyen · · 100 points

    Half my hero shots are the render I did while reaching for the stop button.

  • @oliviatanaka_films393 · · 46 points

    Counterpoint: at some point 41 renders is more expensive than just shooting a real window with a real camera phone and a $30 dolly.

  • @yukisantos_ai · · 74 points

    For ONE shot sure. For a 40-shot short where I need stylistic consistency, no chance. The phone can't match the look across the whole thing.

  • @hananguyenlab · · 54 points

    Found the guy who's never tried to color match 40 phone clips at 2am.