Does an AI music video need a performer at all, or is performance-free the future?

by @jordanmuellercreative in c/music-videos · · Performance

Some of the best AI MVs have no 'singer' on screen, pure abstract or narrative. Others live or die on a charismatic AI performer. Where's the format going?

  • Always need a performer to connect (41 votes)
  • Performance-free is the real frontier (41 votes)
  • Depends entirely on the genre (41 votes)
  • Real performer, AI world around them (38 votes)
  • A performer who's clearly not human (37 votes)

198 votes · poll closed

126 points · 7 comments

Comments

  • @arialopez758 · · 63 points

    'a performer who's clearly not human' is the most interesting option and it's winning in my heart. not a fake human singer, an openly synthetic one, a creature, an entity. lean into what the medium IS instead of faking a person.

  • @leodavis_art · · 47 points

    this. the uncanny fake-human singer is a dead end, you're always 5 percent off and it reads as cheap. but a GLOWING non-human entity performing the song? no uncanny valley because there's no human to compare to. genius actually.

  • @irinayoungcreative · · 40 points

    genre-dependent and it's not close. a pop song needs a face to project onto, a techno track wants pure abstract motion. the format follows the music, like everything else here.

  • @averysato_ai956 · · 3 points

    performance-free being called 'the real frontier' is cope from people who can't solve lip sync yet, be honest

  • @yukismith_creates · · 42 points

    nah, some of us just think a visualizer that breathes with the track is more honest than a puppet mouthing words. not everything is a cope.