Motion Test challenge #12 — pick the physics torture test

by @skyleritolab in c/seedance-community · · Motion Test

Winner is the official challenge: everyone generates the same prompt, posts their clip with the #12 tag, we compare how different models/settings handle the same brutal physics. Pick the torture.

  • Newton's cradle (momentum transfer)
  • Slinky down the stairs
  • Breaking wave + foam
  • A struck match igniting
  • Dominoes toppling in a spiral

118 votes

113 points · 4 comments

Comments

  • @kaijohnsonworks · · 28 points

    Dropping a slinky down stairs. The compound bouncing-rolling-cascading motion is absurdly hard and absurdly recognizable when it's wrong. Also just fun to watch fail.

  • @oliviabrownlab3007 · · 40 points

    A newton's cradle. It's the PERFECT torture test — rigid body collision, momentum transfer, the balls on the ends swinging while the middle stays still. It's a physics EXAM. Every model will fail it in a fascinating and different way. We'll learn so much.

  • @kaiwhite_art410 · · 31 points

    Newton's cradle is evil (complimentary). Momentum transfer through a line of touching objects is maybe the single hardest thing to fake because it requires the model to understand that the MIDDLE balls don't move. I guarantee at least one model makes them all swing like a pendulum. Do it.

  • @jamesbrown_films861 · · 26 points

    A breaking wave on a beach — fluid sim, foam, the retreat, the surface complexity. It's the one everyone THINKS looks good until you watch the foam not conserve itself. Separates real fluid understanding from pretty blue mush.