The Peace Treaty (pinned): AI-assisted pixel art is allowed here IF it's cleaned to a real grid and tagged. Hand artists, read this too.

by @yukimartinez in c/pixel-art · · Mod Post

We've had the war. Multiple times. Here's the treaty that keeps this sub from splitting in two.

AI-assisted pixel art is allowed — but 'I typed pixel art into a video model and posted the mush' is NOT. If it's AI-origin, it must be:
Cleaned to an actual pixel grid. One consistent pixel size, no stray anti-aliasing, no half-pixels. If I can see three different pixel sizes in one sprite, it's not done, it's a draft.
Tagged honestly. Say it was AI-assisted. Nobody's ashamed, we just want to know.
Palette-disciplined. Pick a palette and HOLD it. 4000 colors masquerading as pixel art fools no one.

Hand artists: the gatekeeping stops at 'is the final piece good pixel art', not 'did a human place every pixel'. A cleaned Retro Diffusion piece that respects the grid is welcome. A sloppy hand-drawn one still gets critiqued. The grid doesn't care how you got there.

This month's Jam: one 32x32 sprite, max 8 colors, any theme. Grid must be perfect. Go.

476 points · 11 comments

Comments

  • @nikolaichen_studio · · 71 points

    zoomed in to check the grid and it's clean, which is more than I can say for half of what gets posted. you did the work.

  • @marcusnguyen_creates · · 86 points

    'the grid doesn't care how you got there' is the most mature take I've seen on this whole fight. judge the pixels, not the pipeline. a clean grid is a clean grid.

  • @oscarbrownlab · · 83 points

    the problem is 90% of the AI pixel art posted elsewhere does NOT respect the grid and the people posting it genuinely can't SEE that it's broken. the three-pixel-sizes thing is invisible to them. that's the real divide — not AI vs hand, but trained eye vs untrained.

  • @zaraalmeidacreative · · 92 points

    as someone who's hand-placed pixels for 12 years: this is right and it took me a while to accept it. the craft is in the RESTRAINT — the palette discipline, the clean grid, the readability at size. a tool that gets you to a clean grid faster isn't cheating, it's a tool. a tool that lets you SKIP the discipline is the actual problem.

  • @akirakapoor_art780 · · 22 points

    downvoting because 'AI pixel art' is an oxymoron and cleaning mush on a grid is still mush with extra steps. but I appreciate the mods trying. we just fundamentally disagree on what the craft IS.

  • @emmapark_fx427 · · 91 points

    genuine question, not a gotcha: if a piece ends up with a perfect grid, disciplined palette, and reads great at 1x, and you literally cannot tell how it was made — is it still mush? where exactly is the line for you?