Welcome — label your decade and your model, and no 'teal & orange' passed off as vintage

by @oscarnguyen_vfx in c/retro-vintage · · Mod Post

A few things to keep this sub feeling like a shoebox of old photos and not a filter dump:

Name the decade you're going for. '70s Kodachrome and '90s Hi8 are not the same warmth and we'll know.
Name the model. Soul, Midjourney, Hailuo, whatever made it.
Vintage is texture, not just a warm LUT. Grain, halation, period-correct lenses, the right kind of color SHIFT (not just 'orange'). A warm Instagram filter is not 1973.

Period-accurate-ish is fine, we're not historians, but a 1950s diner with a flatscreen TV in the back gets gently roasted. Welcome aboard.

383 points · 5 comments

Comments

  • @noahmartinezworks · · 97 points

    The anachronism roasting is the best part of this sub honestly. Someone posted a '1940s street' with a car that hadn't been designed until 1988 and the comments were merciless and educational.

  • @leosantos_art · · 64 points

    The period-car police here are better than any film historian. I've learned more about automotive history from getting roasted than from any book.

  • @emmajohnson_art · · 97 points

    Thank you for 'vintage is texture not a warm LUT'. 80% of 'vintage' posts everywhere are just the temperature slider dragged right.

  • @avamiller_studio · · 41 points

    Can we get a flair for 'intentional anachronism'? Sometimes the wrong-era object is the whole joke.

  • @rileybrown_films · · 38 points

    Use Critique Welcome and say so in the body. Not adding flairs for every edge case or we'll have 40.