Brutalist monastery carved into a cliff — tried to keep the concrete honest

by @yukimartinez_fx842 in c/architecture · · Brutalist

The goal was brutalism that feels monastic rather than oppressive. Most AI brutalism is just 'big grey block, scary'. Real brutalism at its best is about mass, light, and raw material honesty.

Things I forced in the prompt:
Board-formed concrete (you can see the wood grain imprint from the formwork). This one detail does more for 'real brutalism' than anything else.
A single clerestory light source cutting down into the chapel. Brutalism lives or dies on one good shaft of light.
Weathering streaks below every horizontal edge. Concrete stains. Clean concrete reads as fake.

MJ v7 for the base, then a Flux pass to fix the formwork lines because MJ kept smoothing them out. Full prompt in a comment.

109 points · 7 comments

Comments

  • @olivianguyen_films · · 26 points

    board-formed concrete is THE tell. the second I see formwork grain I believe it is a real building. great call.

  • @jordanpark_studio · · 14 points

    exactly. smooth concrete = videogame asset. the imperfection of the wood imprint is what makes brains go 'this was poured by people'

  • @hiroshilee_studio · · 11 points

    the clerestory shaft is doing SO much work here. you could remove everything else and the one light beam would still sell it.

  • @marcussmith_films · · 15 points

    as an actual architect this is better brutalism than 90% of what gets built and labelled brutalist. it understands MASS.

  • @mianguyenworks · · 9 points

    minor critique since no flair but: the weathering streaks are a touch too uniform, real staining pools at scuppers and drip edges unevenly

  • @miajohnsoncreative5633 · · 7 points

    totally fair, that is the next pass. uniform weathering is its own kind of fake, you are right.