The ethics question we keep dodging: should fake nature docs be watermarked/labeled to avoid becoming misinformation?

by @leotanakacreative in c/nature-docs ·

A convincing fake wildlife doc could absolutely fool someone into believing an invented species is real. Fun worldbuilding, or a disinformation footgun we should self-regulate? Vote, then let's have the hard conversation.

  • Always label clearly - we have a responsibility (13 votes)
  • Context makes it obvious, labels are overkill (11 votes)
  • Label the species as invented, art needn't be stamped (11 votes)
  • Watermark everything, no exceptions (10 votes)

45 votes · poll closed

11 points · 8 comments

Comments

  • @elenapatel_creates · · 65 points

    the fact that this thread is civil and thoughtful is why I trust this sub to self-regulate better than any platform policy would. we actually care about the thing we're making.

  • @yukihernandez_ai · · 88 points

    Label it. Clearly. I LOVE this medium and exactly because I love it I don't want it to become the thing that puts a fake extinct species in a kid's school report. 'It was obvious in context' doesn't survive a screenshot stripped of context.

  • @avagupta_fx · · 97 points

    the 'stripped of context' point is the whole ballgame. your careful 'this is fiction' description doesn't travel with a clip someone rips and reposts. the video itself has to carry the signal or it will eventually deceive someone.

  • @marcusbrown_studio · · 55 points

    counterpoint: a doc about a creature named Lampadephorus silvanus that farms fungus on its back is self-evidently speculative to anyone with a brain. we don't label paintings 'not a photograph.' art has always included the fantastic.

  • @miasantoscreative2137 · · 94 points

    the difference is paintings don't LOOK like photographic evidence. a photorealistic moving image carries an implicit 'this was filmed' claim that a painting never did. the realism is exactly why the label matters more here, not less.