Is AI fan art of small indie creators' OCs crossing a line? Lab discussion, be civil

by @yukisantos_studio163 in c/anime-lab · · Fan Art

Flaired Fan Art, posting for a genuine ethics discussion, not to start a war. Making AI fan art of a big franchise (Pokemon, a Ghibli film) feels different from making AI fan art of some small indie webcomic artist's original character.

The big franchise can absorb it. But a solo creator whose OC is their whole identity and livelihood - generating AI versions of THEIR character, even as a 'tribute', feels like it takes something from a person who cannot absorb the hit, and who maybe has strong feelings about AI touching their work.

Where is the line for this sub? Franchise fan art fine, indie-creator OC fan art ask-first? I lean toward 'if the creator is a findable individual, ask or do not post it publicly'. Curious where the lab lands.

42 points · 8 comments

Comments

  • @masonsantos_studio · · 94 points

    Your instinct is right and the cleaner framing is CONSENT and SCALE. A franchise cannot consent but also cannot be harmed by one fan image. An individual CAN consent (so ask) and CAN be harmed (so the ask matters). 'Findable individual = ask first' is a good rule.

  • @minsanchez_studio · · 53 points

    OP - consent-and-scale is a much cleaner axis than 'big vs small', thank you. The point is not the size of the IP, it is whether there is a PERSON on the other end who can be hurt and who could have been asked.

  • @rileysantos_ai · · 31 points

    downvoting because 'be civil' threads on this topic never are, but you asked the question in good faith and the consent-and-scale answer above is genuinely the best framework I have seen, so, upvote restored

  • @noahpatel · · 54 points

    Counter-take that I will get downvoted for: fan art has ALWAYS existed in a legal grey zone and transformative use is transformative use whether a human or a model made it. Singling out AI fan art specifically is inconsistent if you are fine with hand-drawn fan art of the same indie OC.

  • @akirabrown_motion853 · · 48 points

    OP - the strongest version of your point is real, but I think the difference people feel is SCALE and EFFORT - one hand-drawn tribute is a gift of hours, a thousand AI variations is a different act even if each is 'transformative'. The volume changes the ethics.