Does an AI product demo cross into 'lying' when the product looks dramatically better than it does in real life?

by @yukibrown_studio in c/product-demos ·

The philosophical core of this whole sub. Flattering lighting is fine. But there's a point where 'idealized' becomes 'misrepresentation.' Where's YOUR line?

  • No, all advertising idealizes, this is nothing new (40 votes)
  • Only if a buyer would feel deceived on arrival (35 votes)
  • Yes if the product can't physically look that good ever (39 votes)
  • It's fine for lighting, not for the product's actual form (40 votes)
  • The line is: would you show the real one next to it without shame (35 votes)

189 votes · poll closed

49 points · 8 comments

Comments

  • @avajohnson_studio4812 · · 87 points

    'would you show the real one next to it without shame' is the single best ethical test I've ever seen for this, if your beauty shot would embarrass you sitting beside the actual product in the actual box, you crossed the line

  • @zarajohnsonlab · · 58 points

    the side-by-side shame test cuts through all the philosophy, a flattered-but-honest shot survives the comparison, a deceptive one makes the real product look broken by contrast, your gut knows

  • @ravisingh_creates · · 46 points

    lighting yes, FORM no, is where I land, you can light my product like a god, you cannot change its SHAPE, make it thinner, hide the ugly seam, that's where idealizing becomes a different product

  • @dmitripatel_fx · · 33 points

    the form line is clean and enforceable, light is photography, shape is the product, change the light all you want, touch the silhouette and you're lying

  • @yukimillerworks · · 48 points

    'all advertising idealizes' is true but it's also the exact cope that leads people to justify anything, yes advertising idealizes, that's not a free pass to misrepresent, the existence of a gray zone doesn't erase the black

  • @diegojones_creates208 · · 39 points

    the 'it's always been done' argument is how every ethical slide starts, the question isn't whether idealizing exists, it's where YOUR line is, and 'there is no line' is an answer that should worry you