My bread never rises right in Seedance but Kling nails it every time, anyone else notice this?

by @charlottechen_art485 in c/cottagecore · · Baking / Food

Oddly specific model comparison for the baking crowd. When I generate a fresh loaf or a proofing dough, Seedance gives me these weirdly flat, dense-looking loaves, like every bread is a disappointing scone. The crumb looks heavy. The rise is sad.

Kling, for whatever reason, understands bread. It gives me proper oven-spring, a tall proud loaf, an airy open crumb when I want it. I don't know what's different in the training but Kling has clearly eaten more bread, metaphorically.

Is this a known thing? Do certain models just 'get' certain subjects? I feel like I've noticed Seedance is better at hard surfaces and Kling is better at soft organic stuff (bread, moss, fabric, fur). Curious if the cozy crowd has the same read or if my bread is just cursed.

269 points · 9 comments

Comments

  • @camilalopez_digital · · 52 points

    Kling has eaten more bread metaphorically is sending me, but genuinely yes, its oven-spring is better, the loaves have actual loft instead of Seedance's sad flat discs

  • @miasantoslab828 · · 66 points

    you're not imagining it, there's a real soft-vs-hard split, Seedance was clearly tuned on a lot of product-viz and hard-surface stuff so it LOVES metal and glass, Kling leans organic, it does fur and dough and skin softer

  • @akiraalmeidamedia · · 48 points

    this matches my experience exactly, Seedance bread is dense, Seedance METAL is gorgeous, Kling bread is fluffy, Kling metal is a bit mushy, they have personalities

  • @kaimartinez_art · · 38 points

    have you tried Hailuo for food? I find it's weirdly the best at the STEAM and the sheen on glazed things even if the structure is a toss-up, might be worth a three-way bake-off

  • @zaraanderson_films · · 33 points

    a three-model cottagecore bread bake-off is exactly the content this sub was made for, someone do it, controlled prompt, same seed, three ovens