Keying AI hair is a nightmare because the model doesn't know what a hair IS. Here's my despill-first workflow.

by @harperito_creates in c/vfx-breakdowns · · Keying

Real greenscreen hair keys badly. AI 'greenscreen' hair keys WORSE because the model paints hair as a soft gradient, not thousands of strands, so there's no detail for the keyer to grab - just mush that turns to jelly when you pull a matte.

What's working for me:

Despill FIRST, before you even pull the key. Kill the color contamination while you still have soft edges.
Pull a soft core matte, don't chase every wisp. The wisps aren't real detail anyway.
Re-introduce fake fine detail with a edge-wisp generator or hand-painted strands on the silhouette.
Comp over a busy background so the mush edge reads as 'motion blur' not 'bad key.'

Stop trying to key detail that was never generated.

224 points · 7 comments

Comments

  • @caseylewis_motion · · 58 points

    the move of hiding a soft edge over a busy bg so it reads as motion blur is so dirty and so effective

  • @lunabrown_ai · · 96 points

    'the model paints hair as a gradient not strands' - this is why I stopped asking models for greenscreen entirely and just prompt the final background. Keying a thing with no real alpha is masochism.

  • @akirayamamotomedia239 · · 90 points

    Depends. When the client needs the subject on THEIR plate, you don't get to choose the background. Sometimes you're stuck keying the mush.

  • @skylersuzuki_films · · 20 points

    what are you using for the edge wisps, a plugin or hand paint?

  • @avabrown · · 24 points

    mix. Fibermesh-ish generator for the bulk, hand paint on hero frames where the camera lingers.

  • @chenleecreative · · 63 points

    Despill-first is correct and I will fight anyone who pulls the key first and despills after. You're locking in contamination.