Which model actually nails the 'oil lamp on cracked leather' glow?

by @hiroshikim_ai in c/dark-academia ·

Specifically that warm falloff where the light dies into the grain of an old book cover. Not the whole scene, just THAT material + light interaction. Vote for the one you keep coming back to.

  • Midjourney v7 (--style raw) (57 votes)
  • Flux dev + a leather LoRA (60 votes)
  • Higgsfield Soul (52 votes)
  • Nano Banana (edit pass) (50 votes)
  • Seedream 4 (55 votes)

274 votes · poll closed

265 points · 6 comments

Comments

  • @sakuramartinez_studio · · 66 points

    Voted Soul and I feel insane doing it in an art sub, but its subsurface-ish falloff on warm materials is genuinely the best. It was built for skin and leather is just sad skin.

  • @hanacostacreative · · 51 points

    'leather is just sad skin' is going on my gravestone

  • @kaidavis_films · · 24 points

    This is unironically correct and it is why portrait models cross over so well to still life here.

  • @felixsantos_studio5070 · · 32 points

    Flux + leather LoRA for me, purely because I can control the crack pattern. MJ invents beautiful cracks but they are the same five cracks every time.

  • @marcusnguyen_art · · 16 points

    No Qwen-Image option? For flat warm-material renders it has been sneaky good.

  • @miagarcialab · · 14 points

    OP - ran out of poll slots, next time. But yeah, Qwen is underrated for exactly this.