Unpopular: Niji still beats every 'anime' VIDEO model because motion models cannot hold line weight

by @kaibrownworks425 in c/anime-lab ·

Hot take for the lab. Everyone is hyped on anime video (Kling anime mode, Wan, etc.) but I think still-image Niji + manual animation is STILL the higher ceiling for real anime, and here is the core reason: video models cannot hold consistent LINE WEIGHT.

Anime is defined by its LINE - the varying thickness, the clean closure, the way a line tapers. Every video model treats line as a texture that it re-renders every frame, so the lines BOIL - thickness wobbles, closures open and shut, the whole thing shimmers like it is underwater. A Niji still has a clean authored line. A Kling anime clip has a boiling approximation of a line.

Until a video model can treat the line as a stable vector-like element frame to frame, 'anime video' will keep looking like a watercolor of anime, not anime. Change my mind.

31 points · 9 comments

Comments

  • @dmitrimartinez_fx92 · · 96 points

    You are right about the line boiling and wrong that it means Niji wins. The actual answer is the separate-line-pass applied to VIDEO: generate the color motion in Kling, then run a consistent lineart pass on top. The line boils because it is entangled with color. Separate it and stabilize it.

  • @jordanclarklab · · 62 points

    OP - ok if a stable separate-line-pass over video motion is achievable that genuinely weakens my take, but I have not seen anyone actually HOLD that line pass stable across frames. Temporal consistency on the line is the exact unsolved problem. Show me a clip where the line does not boil.

  • @oliviajohnson_studio4957 · · 71 points

    Counter: 'anime' does not require perfect line stability, early TV anime BOILS constantly (budget, xerox lines) and we love it. Maybe boiling-line AI anime should lean into a lo-fi 70s TV aesthetic where boil reads as CHARM not failure.

  • @yukimiller_art4389 · · 47 points

    OP - this is actually a smart cope and I respect it, reframe the boil as deliberate retro texture. Does not get you clean MODERN anime but it is a legit aesthetic lane. Fine, you half-changed my mind.

  • @zaramartinez · · 39 points

    downvoted because 'change my mind' posts are insufferable, but the line-boiling diagnosis is 100% correct and the single biggest tell of AI anime video, so, conflicted upvote too