Comparison: Soul vs Midjourney v7 vs Flux on the EXACT same portrait prompt — honest grid

by @felixtanaka_films3073 in c/soul-community · · Comparison

Comparison: Soul vs Midjourney v7 vs Flux on the EXACT same portrait prompt — honest grid
Same prompt, same seed philosophy, three models, no cherry-picking (I'm showing the first non-broken gen from each). Portrait of a tired barista at closing time, warm practical light. Trying to be fair — each has a clear personality. Full grid and my honest read on who won which category in the link
twitter.com

Same prompt, same seed philosophy, three models, no cherry-picking (I'm showing the first non-broken gen from each). Portrait of a tired barista at closing time, warm practical light. Trying to be fair — each has a clear personality. Full grid and my honest read on who won which category in the link. Spoiler: nobody swept.

346 points · 8 comments

Comments

  • @emmadavis3763 · · 48 points

    Your read tracks exactly with mine: Soul won SKIN and worst PROMPT ADHERENCE (it ignored the 'tired' and gave you a glowing model), MJ won MOOD and lost REALISM, Flux won the BALANCE and wowed at nothing. That's the eternal triangle right now.

  • @ameliamehtamedia · · 37 points

    'Soul ignored tired and gave you a glowing model' is SO real. Soul wants everyone beautiful and well-rested. Prompting exhaustion, bags, slack jaw — it resists every one. Its beauty bias is its biggest adherence weakness.

  • @sashadavisworks · · 70 points

    Appreciate the no-cherry-pick rule, these comparison posts are usually rigged by picking each model's best gen and it tells you nothing. First-valid-gen is the only honest methodology. Respect.

  • @charlottelopezmedia189 · · 44 points

    Cherry-picked comparisons are marketing, not information. 'Here's model X's 1-in-50 banger vs model Y's median' is how every fanboy 'proves' their favorite. First-gen or it's worthless.

  • @ravigarcia_vfx · · 34 points

    Flux winning 'the balance and wowing at nothing' is the most Flux sentence ever written. It's the reliable sedan of image models. Never thrilling, never strands you. There's a real place for that.

  • @lio_toons · · 22 points

    Would love to see Seedream in the next one, it's conspicuously absent from these comparisons and I think it'd surprise people on the warm-practical-light prompt specifically.

  • @sashapatel_creates · · 18 points

    Next grid, promise. Four-way with Seedream. The warm-light category is exactly where I hear it punches above its reputation.