What breaks a character's believability FASTEST for you as a viewer?

by @noahsmithcreative1678 in c/character-animation ·

Watching someone else's AI character work, what's the first thing that yanks you out and makes you go 'oh, it's fake'?

  • Face drift / cousin drift between shots (67 votes)
  • Dead eyes during dialogue (56 votes)
  • Lip-sync that's slightly off the audio (58 votes)
  • Outfit/hair changing details shot to shot (60 votes)
  • Unnatural, floaty body movement (60 votes)
  • Emotionless 'reading the line' delivery (55 votes)

356 votes · poll closed

345 points · 6 comments

Comments

  • @hiroshiwilliams379 · · 98 points

    dead eyes, instantly, every time. you can forgive a LOT of technical jank if the eyes are alive, and you can forgive NOTHING if they're dead. a slightly drifting face with living eyes beats a perfect face with the thousand-yard stare. the eyes are the soul and the brain checks them first.

  • @kaipatel_films7857 · · 93 points

    this is why I rank performance tools over pure-consistency tools. a rock-solid consistent character who's dead behind the eyes is a mannequin. I'd rather have 5% cousin drift and a real performance. identity without soul is just a 3D model.

  • @elenatanakalab4876 · · 51 points

    saving the approach. 'consistency is a pipeline not a setting' is the lesson I keep relearning and your results prove it.

  • @jordanmueller_studio680 · · 68 points

    lip-sync being slightly off is my personal nails-on-chalkboard. even 2 frames of offset and my brain SCREAMS. it's the dubbing-a-foreign-film feeling. weirdly I'd rather have no lip movement than slightly-wrong lip movement.

  • @isabellamillermedia · · 49 points

    slightly-wrong sync is worse than no sync for the same reason the slow face melt is worse than instant jank — your brain commits to it as real, THEN catches the error, and the betrayal is the uncanny. a closed mouth your brain never commits to.