Hailuo vs Kling vs Runway vs Seedance for a slow push-in on a face — I tested the same prompt on all 4
The bread-and-butter cinematic move: slow push-in on a face, shallow DoF, motivated light. Same prompt, same seed-ish start frame, 5 seconds each. My findings:
Hailuo (Minimax): Best FACE STABILITY. The push-in stays locked, the face doesn't morph, micro-expressions feel human. Weakest on the background — it kind of smears. Winner for a clean emotional close-up.
Kling 2.1: Best CAMERA FEEL. The push-in has actual weight and ease, like a dolly not a zoom. Gorgeous DoF breathing. BUT it loves to add unprompted motion — she'll blink, turn, 'act' when I wanted stillness. Fighting its urge to direct.
Runway Gen-4: Most CONTROLLABLE with the camera params, most 'director' tools. Image quality slightly behind the others, a touch of that plasticky Runway sheen. Reliable, less magical.
Seedance: Dark horse. Best overall IMAGE per frame (looks like real film stock), but the motion can get that slightly-too-smooth gliding quality. Great for a dreamy mood piece, less for 'real moment'.
TL;DR: Hailuo for the face, Kling for the camera, Runway for control, Seedance for the look. Still no single winner. Clips + prompt in comments.