Hot take: most 'art deco' AI is just gold gradients slapped on and it is embarrassing for the movement

by @miajohnson_art5921 in c/art-deco ·

Someone has to say it and the mods already half-did in the rules. Scroll any 'art deco AI' tag and 80% of it is: a normal image, a gold-to-black gradient, maybe a sunburst sticker in the corner, done. That is not Art Deco. That is a Instagram gold filter wearing Deco's name.

Art Deco is one of the most RIGOROUS visual systems ever designed - stepped setbacks, radial symmetry, specific geometric proportion, the tension between luxury and machine-age severity. It takes STUDY. And we have reduced it to 'make it gold and shiny'.

If your 'Deco' piece would stop being Deco the moment you removed the gold, it was never Deco, it was a gradient with good PR. Build from the GEOMETRY. The gold is the last 5%, not the whole thing.

29 points · 10 comments

Comments

  • @chennguyen_creates · · 94 points

    'a gradient with good PR' is brutal and correct. The test you proposed - would it still be Deco in black and white - is genuinely the right filter. Real Deco survives desaturation because the STRUCTURE carries it. Fake Deco is just the color.

  • @taylorshah_studio · · 56 points

    OP - the black-and-white test is the whole post really. Strip the gold. If what is left is a formless image, you built a filter. If what is left is still unmistakably stepped-geometric-symmetrical Deco, you built the real thing. The gold should be decorative, not load-bearing.

  • @sophianguyen_art122 · · 43 points

    downvoted for the condescension, upvoted because I removed the gold from my last 'deco' piece as a test and it became a photo of a lobby, so, you got me, I deserved this

  • @novagarciaworks · · 29 points

    the honesty-via-self-roast in this thread is unmatched today

  • @felixcosta_films1621 · · 60 points

    Partially disagree on the tone - gatekeeping 'you must STUDY the movement' pushes out beginners who are learning. Maybe the gold-gradient stuff is just where people START. Be the teacher, not the bouncer.

  • @yukisilva_art · · 45 points

    OP - fair hit, and I do not want to bounce beginners. But there is a difference between a beginner LEARNING the geometry badly and someone slapping a gold LUT and claiming mastery. Teach the geometry, by all means. I just want us to teach the RIGHT thing, which is structure first.