Soul vs the field: which model actually wins on SKIN specifically?

by @zaragarcialab9363 in c/soul-community · · Comparison

Not overall. Not prompt adherence. Not composition. Purely: which renders the most convincing real human SKIN out of the box? Settle it.

  • Soul (tuned) (40 votes)
  • Flux (38 votes)
  • Midjourney v7 (37 votes)
  • Seedream (36 votes)
  • They're all close, it's a prompt/lighting problem now (23 votes)

174 votes · poll closed

166 points · 6 comments

Comments

  • @minharris_creates · · 60 points

    Soul, but with the asterisk that it's only true once you've learned to prompt AGAINST its default plastic. Out of the absolute box, default settings, it's waxier than you'd think. Tuned, nothing touches it on skin. Untuned, it's mid. The ceiling is highest, the floor is not.

  • @sergeibecker_digital · · 44 points

    The ceiling-vs-floor distinction is the honest answer to every one of these polls. Soul's ceiling is the best skin in the game. Its floor is plastic. Flux's floor is higher but its ceiling is lower. Depends if you'll do the work.

  • @ravisinghlab6956 · · 27 points

    Honestly Seedream surprised me on skin lately, warmer and less uncanny by default than people give it credit for. Dark horse. Won't win this poll but it deserves a mention.

  • @kaifischer_vfx · · 30 points

    Midjourney v7 makes the prettiest skin and the fakest. It's the magazine-retouch look dialed to 11. Gorgeous, never believable. Different goal entirely.

  • @henrysingh_digital949 · · 36 points

    Flux has the more consistent skin OUT of the box imo, less waxy by default, but it tops out lower — it can't hit the hyper-real pore-level detail Soul can when Soul's dialed in. Reliability vs peak.