Three days fighting Seedance to stop it melting the hull plating on my O'Neill cylinder

by @ethangarcia_creates in c/sci-fi-concepts · · Megastructure

I wanted a proper rotating habitat, land curving up the walls, the whole Rama thing. Every single generation the hull plating turned into this wet molten chrome that looked like a Salvador Dali clock.

What finally worked: I stopped saying 'metal hull' entirely. I described it as 'riveted ceramic tile, matte, aged' and prompted the panel grid explicitly. The moment I took the word metal out, the melting stopped. The model clearly has some cursed association between 'metal + curved + large' and liquid mercury.

Second thing: render the interior landscape and the hull as separate passes and comp them. Trying to get the curve-up horizon AND clean plating in one shot was fighting itself every time. Stills in comments.

433 points · 8 comments

Comments

  • @oscarsmith_art · · 88 points

    'melting chrome Dali clock' is every single large-scale metal prompt I have ever written, you're not alone

  • @oscarthomascreative · · 53 points

    it's the training data. renders of 'huge metal thing' skew toward chrome product viz and liquid metal VFX

  • @minsouza_digital358 · · 37 points

    Rama mention, instant upvote. Did you get the far side of the cylinder to read as sky-but-also-ground or did you fog it out?

  • @sophiacosta_films · · 29 points

    fogged it. atmospheric haze at ~8km does the heavy lifting and hides the fact the model can't hold detail that far.

  • @sakurapatel_creates8317 · · 31 points

    saving this entire post. the 'take the word metal out' insight is worth a whole tutorial

  • @oscartanakacreative · · 17 points

    Kling handles curved megastructures better in my experience but you lose the surface detail you got here. tradeoffs.