Diver's exhaled bubbles keep rising SIDEWAYS in Runway Gen-4 - anyone solved bubble physics?

by @pia_sound in c/underwater · · WIP

WIP, driving me insane. Diver exhales, bubbles should wobble upward, expand as they rise, and break into smaller ones. Instead Gen-4 sends them drifting horizontally like the diver is in a wind tunnel.

Tried prompting bubbles rise vertically toward the surface, expanding, wobbling. Gen-4 nods politely and sends them sideways anyway. Is this a known Runway weakness? Does Kling or Hailuo handle rising-bubble buoyancy better?

142 points · 7 comments

Comments

  • @reesesuzuki_art200 · · 44 points

    Cheese it: put the camera at a slight low angle looking up. Then 'toward the surface' is clearly out-of-frame-top and the model has fewer directions to screw up. Constrain the geometry.

  • @sophiasilva_art6799 · · 22 points

    OP - clever, give the bubbles only one sensible way out of frame. Trying that too.

  • @theomehta_art · · 57 points

    Runway has no real concept of 'up' in water. It treats the whole frame as neutral-gravity space. Hailuo at least knows buoyancy exists. Switch models for bubble shots specifically.

  • @chensantos_studio8517 · · 31 points

    OP - so it is a fundamental Gen-4 blind spot, not me prompting wrong. Weirdly relieving. Testing Hailuo.

  • @sakurasinghlab · · 29 points

    honestly sideways bubbles are the aquatic cousin of sideways-rising smoke and every video model has done it to me at least once

  • @irinathomas_art814 · · 26 points

    if all else fails, bubbles are one of the easier things to comp in post, a particle layer over the clip fixes it in 10 min