Discussion: 'prompt engineering' as a term is on borrowed time and that's fine

by @rileysilva_vfx8008 in c/prompt-engineering · · Discussion

Spicy discussion take. As models get better at understanding plain intent, the elaborate syntax-wrangling we call 'prompt engineering' is shrinking every release. The models meet us halfway more each time.

I don't think the SKILL dies though — it just moves. It stops being 'know the magic incantation' and becomes 'know what you actually want, describe it clearly, and understand what the tool can and can't do.' That's just... creative direction. Communication.

The weird syntax era is ending. The clear-thinking era is beginning. The people clutching their 60-token negative blocks will be fine, they'll just be doing something closer to directing than coding. Change my mind.

49 points · 7 comments

Comments

  • @jamessantos_creates · · 99 points

    You're right and it's the healthiest possible evolution. The skill was never the syntax, the syntax was scar tissue from models that couldn't understand us. As that heals, clarity of intent is what's left. That's a BETTER skill.

  • @hiroshilewis_films · · 88 points

    'Syntax as scar tissue from models that couldn't understand us' is a genuinely great line. The weighting hacks were workarounds, not the art. The art was always knowing what you wanted.

  • @chenthomas_digital990 · · 61 points

    As someone who came from photography, this is already true for me. I 'prompt' by describing lighting and lens like I'm briefing a DP. The models that fight that are just the old ones.

  • @anastasiaschmidt_studio · · 47 points

    The 60-token-negative-block people are this sub's spirit animal and I say that with love as one of them.

  • @irinascott_films · · 68 points

    Pushback: there will ALWAYS be an edge where the model doesn't understand intent and you need to know its quirks. The frontier keeps moving but there's always a frontier. The syntax-wrangling moves to the newest/weirdest tools, it doesn't vanish.

  • @jordanlee_films · · 54 points

    Fair — the discipline survives at the bleeding edge even as it dies in the mainstream. Prompt engineering becomes a frontier skill, not a universal one. I'll take that amendment.