Six glaze layers vs one pass — the depth is not even close (comparison)

by @sakurasanchezworks620 in c/oil-painting · · Glazing

People keep saying you can't 'build up' a painting in a one-shot generator and they're half right. You can fake the result of glazing though.

Left image: single prompt, 'luminous glazed oil portrait, Rembrandt'. Looks fine. Flat.

Right image: I generated the base warm underpainting, then img2img at 0.35 denoise with a prompt that only added a cool shadow glaze, then again at 0.25 adding a warm light glaze, repeat. Each pass only changes one optical layer. By pass six the shadows have that bottomless brown-black depth you only get from transparent darks over a warm ground.

Key is keeping denoise low enough that you're tinting, not regenerating. Above ~0.4 it forgets the previous layer and you're back to flat.

826 points · 7 comments

Comments

  • @chenjohnson_art · · 99 points

    This is basically the only way I've gotten believable darks. Low-denoise glaze passes = transparent paint. High denoise = the model repaints opaquely and kills the depth.

  • @masongarciacreative4135 · · 48 points

    How are you keeping the face from drifting over six passes? Mine turns into a different person by layer 3.

  • @lunabrown · · 66 points

    Mask the face out on the mid passes, only glaze the environment and shadow shapes. Then one final low pass over everything to unify.

  • @jordanito_motion · · 55 points

    the brown-black 'bottomless' shadow is such a Rembrandt thing and nobody's model gets it in one shot. it's always muddy grey instead of warm-transparent-dark.

  • @kaigarcia_vfx · · 22 points

    Six passes is a lot of compute for one image, is it actually worth it vs just painting a glaze layer by hand in Krita over the base?

  • @jordanchen_vfx8811 · · 44 points

    Honestly for a finished piece, painting the final glaze by hand is faster and you have control. The six-pass thing is more a 'what is this model capable of' experiment.