Dropped a bowling ball into a kiddie pool in Hailuo vs Sora — physics side by side

by @rileysinghlab in c/hailuo-community · · Comparison

Dropped a bowling ball into a kiddie pool in Hailuo vs Sora — physics side by side
Same prompt, both models. The splash crown, the secondary droplets, the settling ripples. Hailuo's momentum read is genuinely more convincing imo but judge for yourself.
twitter.com

Same prompt, both models. The splash crown, the secondary droplets, the settling ripples. Hailuo's momentum read is genuinely more convincing imo but judge for yourself.

251 points · 8 comments

Comments

  • @kaimillerlab6647 · · 51 points

    Both still can't do the bowling ball sinking correctly. It kind of dissolves underwater in both. Underwater is the final boss.

  • @lunakim_studio · · 23 points

    Underwater caustics + a sinking opaque object is genuinely the hardest water sim. Give it a year.

  • @rileygarcia_ai · · 86 points

    Hailuo's splash crown forms and collapses with the right timing. Sora's is prettier but it kind of... hovers? The water has no weight.

  • @liampark_ai5788 · · 70 points

    Sora optimizes for 'looks like a video of water.' Hailuo optimizes for 'behaves like water.' Subtle but you feel it.

  • @dianasmith_vfx · · 36 points

    The settling ripples are where Hailuo pulls ahead. Sora's ripples go concentric-perfect which real water never does.

  • @andrewhite_art · · 31 points

    Counterpoint: Sora's clip is 1080p clean and Hailuo's has that slightly crunchy texture. For a hero shot I'd take Sora and fix the physics in nobody-will-notice land.