[Critique Welcome] My ink landscape feels 'busy' but I don't know what to cut. Help me see it.

by @noahtanaka_studio in c/ink-wash · · Critique Welcome

Did a mountain-and-pines ink wash. Technically the strokes are okay I think, but it feels cluttered and anxious rather than serene and I can't tell what's causing it. I suspect I have too much STUFF but I've been staring at it too long to see straight. What would you cut?

10 points · 7 comments

Comments

  • @sakurasmith_creates8918 · · 100 points

    Cut 60% of the pine trees, cut the entire foreground rock cluster, and crop the mountain into the upper-left corner so the bottom-right two-thirds becomes empty mist/water. Your problem isn't the strokes, it's that every zone of the paper has something in it. Serenity needs a large EMPTY zone for the eye to rest.

  • @leilasinghcreative · · 90 points

    oh wow, 'every zone has something in it' - that's exactly it. I filled the whole frame evenly. there's no rest. nowhere for the eye to breathe.

  • @alexeinguyenmedia27 · · 66 points

    count your value steps too - if everything's mid-grey it reads busy. one or two genuinely dark accents (a near pine, a bird) and let everything else go pale. contrast creates a focal point so the eye knows where to land and then rest.

  • @jordanpatelcreative · · 48 points

    for what it's worth the strokes themselves ARE nice. this is a composition/editing fix, not a skill problem. crop and delete, don't repaint.

  • @zarasingh7253 · · 33 points

    that's genuinely reassuring, I thought I needed to start over. crop and delete it is. thank you all.