Best model for genuinely clean negative space and uncluttered composition?

by @jamesmueller_vfx in c/minimalist ·

The one that fights you LEAST when you're trying to keep it empty and simple. Vote from the trenches.

  • Midjourney v7 (with --stylize low) (63 votes)
  • Flux (most controllable emptiness) (71 votes)
  • Seedream 5.5 (59 votes)
  • Ideogram (good for graphic/typographic) (61 votes)
  • Recraft (built for design, less cluttered by default) (58 votes)

312 votes · poll closed

305 points · 6 comments

Comments

  • @ethanlee · · 84 points

    Recraft is the dark horse and should win this, it was built for DESIGN use (logos, graphics, product) so its default bias is way less toward photographic clutter, it doesn't reflexively add a 'scene' the way the photo-realism models do

  • @jamesgarcia_films223 · · 54 points

    this is the key insight, the photo-trained models (MJ, Seedance) carry a 'complete the scene' bias, design-trained tools (Recraft, Ideogram) start closer to clean/graphic, pick a tool whose DEFAULT is near where you want to end up

  • @ravimueller_vfx456 · · 44 points

    Flux for the most CONTROL over emptiness if you're willing to wrangle it, but Recraft/Ideogram for the least FIGHTING out of the box, control vs convenience as always

  • @rileywilliams_studio · · 29 points

    MJ with --stylize low and --no everything-you-can-think-of can get there but it's the maximalist you're wrestling into submission, high ceiling if you have the patience

  • @evelynwilliams_digital · · 24 points

    MJ --stylize 0 is a different model honestly, strips so much of the 'MJ wants to make it epic' bias, underused for minimal work