Unpopular opinion: most AI 'films' in here are tech demos wearing a film costume

by @jamesperez_fx629 in c/ai-filmmakers · · Craft Discussion

Approved Filmmaker flair, so take this as tough love from inside the house, not a hater drive-by. I watch almost everything posted here and I'd estimate 85% of what's called a 'film' is a mood reel: beautiful shots, an ambient drone score, a whispered voiceover of vague profundity, and NO story. No character wants anything. Nothing changes. Nobody's at stake.

A gorgeous sequence of images is not a film. A film needs a person who wants something, an obstacle, and a change. Most of what we celebrate here nails the LOOK and completely skips the SCREENPLAY. We're grading on 'the AI looks good,' not 'the story works.'

The tools are good enough now that 'it looks amazing' should be the floor, not the achievement. Raise the bar to STORY or this medium stays a visual flex forever. Downvote away, I've shipped three of these and I'm criticizing my own early work too.

92 points · 8 comments

Comments

  • @zaramiller_films9360 · · 67 points

    As a writer who came to this from screenwriting, THANK you. The craft conversation here is 90% about images and 10% about story and the ratio is exactly backwards for making actual films.

  • @dianakimworks · · 52 points

    Took the downvote bait, read it, upvoted. My 'film' is a mood reel. Going back to add an actual want-obstacle-change. This hurt and I needed it.

  • @hanamueller_ai8794 · · 71 points

    Partial pushback: some of those 'mood reels' ARE the right form for the tools (see the radio-with-pictures thread). The problem isn't atmosphere, it's atmosphere with NOTHING UNDERNEATH. A mood piece can still have stakes and change.

  • @felixyamamoto_digital460 · · 58 points

    Agreed, this is the nuance. Atmosphere isn't the enemy; emptiness is. La Jetée is 'just' stills and VO and it has more story than 99% of what's posted here. Form isn't the issue, absence of story is.

  • @sashasmith_ai · · 96 points

    You're right and the downvotes you'll get prove it. 'Beautiful mood reel with a profound-sounding VO about memory and time' is a GENRE now and it's a way to avoid the hard part: making someone WANT something on screen.

  • @zarameyerpro394 · · 97 points

    The vague-profundity voiceover is a tell for 'I had no story so I narrated some feelings over pretty pictures.' Real narration serves a story; decorative narration hides the absence of one.