How I get rain that falls in FRONT of and BEHIND the subject (depth trick inside)

by @jinnguyen_motion in c/neon-nights · · Rain

The dead giveaway of fake AI rain: it is all on one plane. A flat sheet of rain pasted over the whole image, same size, same focus, in front of everything. Real rain exists at every depth, some between you and the subject, some far behind, different sizes, different focus.

How I fake real rain depth without 3D:
Generate the scene with rain prompted, but expect the model to give you flat rain. That is your mid-layer.
Generate a SEPARATE pass of just rain streaks on black (prompt 'heavy rain streaks on black background, bokeh'). Two versions: one big and blurry (foreground), one fine and sharp (background).
Composite: sharp fine rain BEHIND the subject (mask it out of the subject), big blurry out-of-focus streaks IN FRONT, over everything including the subject.

Now you have three depth layers of rain and the subject sits INSIDE the weather instead of behind a rain sticker. The big blurry foreground streaks are the secret, real rain-photography always has those huge soft out-of-focus drops near the lens. Example layers in comments.

88 points · 6 comments

Comments

  • @hanamartinez_art · · 25 points

    the big blurry foreground streaks are the THING, every real rain photo has those huge soft drops near the lens and no AI gen includes them because the model renders rain at one distance, this is the fix

  • @nikolaikim_creates · · 14 points

    the out-of-focus foreground rain is what puts the CAMERA in the scene, it implies a lens, a physical position, suddenly there is a photographer standing in the rain instead of a flat render

  • @jordangarcialab3687 · · 13 points

    masking the fine rain BEHIND the subject is the step people skip, if all your rain is in front the subject looks pasted ON the rain instead of IN it, the behind-layer is what integrates them

  • @leosilva_ai · · 8 points

    three-layer rain compositing is more work than most people will do and that is exactly why yours will stand out, the puddle-reflection crowd will not bother, effort is the moat

  • @benjaminpatel_art · · 7 points

    'effort is the moat' is real, the barrier to a GREAT neon shot is not the model it is the willingness to composite three rain passes, most will take the one-click version