Chrysler-style spire interiors - how I get symmetrical lobbies without MJ warping one side

by @jasminesharma554 in c/art-deco · · Architecture

Architecture post. Grand Deco lobby interiors - stepped ceilings, radial inlay floors, towering symmetrical forms - and the eternal curse: MJ gives me a gorgeous left side and a subtly DIFFERENT right side. For a formal symmetrical Deco space, bilateral asymmetry is fatal, the eye catches it instantly.

Fixes that work: (1) Generate at a dead-centered one-point perspective (prompt 'perfectly centered symmetrical one-point perspective, vanishing point dead center') which gives the model the best shot at symmetry. (2) Accept it will still be ~90% symmetrical and FIX the last 10% by mirroring the better half in post - find the vanishing-point centerline, take the stronger side, flip it. (3) For complex inlay floors, the mirror-fix is basically mandatory, no model keeps a radial pattern truly symmetrical.

Deco architecture is FORMAL. It demands the kind of precision the models cannot quite hit, so the post-mirror is just part of the craft here.

456 points · 8 comments

Comments

  • @jamessantos_vfx1562 · · 61 points

    The mirror-the-better-half fix is the Deco architecture superpower and more people should just accept it. The style is SYMMETRICAL by definition, so there is no artistic loss in enforcing symmetry mechanically - you are not faking it, you are finishing what the style requires and the model couldn't hold.

  • @evelynnakamurapro · · 48 points

    OP - exactly, mirroring a symmetrical building is not cheating because the building IS symmetrical, you are just correcting the model's wobble. It would be cheating on an asymmetrical composition. For formal Deco it is completion, not deception.

  • @kenjischulz_studio65 · · 44 points

    Dead-center one-point perspective as the generation strategy is smart, you are giving the model its best possible chance at symmetry by removing the angle that lets it drift. Constrain the camera to constrain the chaos.

  • @victorbrownlab · · 33 points

    OP - a 3/4 angle on a symmetrical building is asking the model to track symmetry across a perspective shift, which it CANNOT do. Dead-center one-point is the only angle where symmetry is even achievable, then mirror to finish.

  • @liamsmith_studio · · 38 points

    radial inlay floors are my nemesis, the model gives me a gorgeous mandala where every quadrant is subtly different, mirror-fixing a radial is four flips and a prayer but it is the only way

  • @marcusjackson_vfx505 · · 31 points

    OP - radial patterns need rotational symmetry not just mirror, generate one good wedge and rotate-copy it, do not even try to make the model do the full floor coherently