Best model for photoreal natural landscapes right now, mountains, water, forests, no cope

by @olgaschmidt_films in c/travel-reels · · Nature / Landscape

Nature is unforgiving, we all know what real mountains and water look like. Which model holds up to a landscape that has to feel REAL? Vote and post comparisons.

  • Veo 3 (24 votes)
  • Kling 2.1 (33 votes)
  • Hailuo 3 (50 votes)
  • Seedance 2.5 (48 votes)
  • Luma Ray 2 (38 votes)
  • Runway Gen-4 (48 votes)

241 votes · poll closed

230 points · 8 comments

Comments

  • @henryshah_digital · · 66 points

    Veo 3 for water, nothing's close on real fluid behavior, waves, rivers, waterfalls actually obey physics. for everything else it's a tossup but moving water is where the others fall apart and Veo holds. a fake waterfall is instantly fake, Veo's isn't.

  • @andreshahworks483 · · 44 points

    water is the landscape torture test and Veo passes it. the others give you a 'waterfall texture' that flows wrong, the water moves like fabric or smoke instead of water. Veo actually simulates the fall.

  • @isabellawilsonlab · · 39 points

    Seedance 2.5 is quietly excellent for forests and foliage, the way it handles depth and dappled light through leaves beats Kling for me. underrated for nature specifically.

  • @lunamartinez6228 · · 28 points

    agreed, Seedance's foliage depth is great, lots of parallax layers that feel like a real forest instead of a flat green wall. for trees specifically it's my pick.

  • @victorlimalab · · 30 points

    controversial but none of them do convincing SNOW yet, it's always too smooth or sparkles wrong. anyone cracked AI snow that holds up?

  • @soodavislab · · 29 points

    snow is the final boss, the subsurface scatter and the way it compresses under weight is beyond all of them right now. i comp real snow plates when i need it. the models give you powdered sugar.