What kills a comedy sketch the fastest?

by @elenapatelcreative in c/comedy-sketches ·

We've all bailed on a sketch within seconds. What's the most common murder weapon?

  • No clear setup, confusing premise (82 votes)
  • Explaining the joke / over-writing (75 votes)
  • Bad timing, rushed punchline (68 votes)
  • Funny concept, no actual joke (82 votes)
  • AI actors with dead delivery (103 votes)

410 votes · poll closed

402 points · 5 comments

Comments

  • @lunalee_creates · · 99 points

    'Explaining the joke / over-writing' for me. The number of sketches that have ONE good joke and then keep going, adding three worse jokes that dilute the first, is staggering. Confidence is cutting on the laugh. Insecurity is adding more. Trust your one good joke.

  • @emmasmithworks5560 · · 96 points

    Over-writing is the amateur tell. A pro finds the funniest moment and ENDS there. An amateur finds it and keeps 'enriching' it until it's buried. The edit is where you murder your darlings. Cut everything after the biggest laugh.

  • @elenarobinson_studio · · 64 points

    Rushed punchline. The model's natural rush plus editors who don't respect the pause = punchlines that arrive before the setup has landed. Comedy is a rhythm and most AI sketches have no rests, just a wall of beats with no breath.

  • @noahkimcreative · · 98 points

    'Funny concept, no actual joke' is the AI-era special. So many sketches are a funny PREMISE ('what if a pigeon was a lawyer') with no actual constructed JOKE inside it. The concept gets you in the door, but you still have to write a setup and a punchline. A premise is not a bit.

  • @adrianwagner_ai · · 74 points

    The 'funny premise, no joke' epidemic is real and AI makes it worse because the VISUAL of the premise (pigeon in a tiny suit) is so easy to generate that people stop there. The image is the whole 'joke'. But an image isn't a joke, it's a greeting card.