Finally cracked melting architecture that breathes instead of just sagging into candle-wax mush

by @taylorsmith in c/surrealist · · Dreamscape

Two weeks fighting this. Every model reads 'melting building' as 'blur downward' and you get wax soup with no structure left.

What worked: clean still of the building in Flux, then image-to-video in Kling 2.1 with the motion prompt aimed at breathing, not melting. 'Facade expands and contracts slowly, windows dilating, stone flexing like a lung, structure intact.' Zero mention of melt. The sag reads as a side effect of the breath and the building stays legible.

Kling held the windows way better than Hailuo here. Hailuo kept inventing new floors between frames. Seed and full prompt in a reply below. It loops, which is the unsettling part. Your eye keeps waiting for it to stop.

403 points · 9 comments

Comments

  • @katyawilliams_ai · · 52 points

    prompt please, the breathing-not-melting reframe is genuinely smart

  • @oscarwebermedia · · 73 points

    Seed 418822, Kling 2.1, motion 0.35. 'ornate stone facade breathing slowly, windows dilating and contracting like pupils, masonry flexing as if a lung is behind it, structure fully intact, no collapse, no dripping, continuous loop.' Negative on 'melting, dripping, wax, collapse.'

  • @felixpatel_vfx · · 43 points

    tried this in Hailuo 3 and it added a gargoyle that wasn't there. twice. different gargoyle each time.

  • @avanguyen_vfx · · 38 points

    Hailuo loves to editorialize. it's great for motion but it will absolutely redecorate your building.

  • @leosilva_art1699 · · 25 points

    this is the first melting-building post that didn't make me want to close the app. respect

  • @mayamillerworks658 · · 11 points

    does it hold up at longer than 5s or does Kling start fighting you

  • @miagarcia_art · · 14 points

    it drifts after about 6s, windows start migrating. i cut and crossfade two 5s loops to get 9s clean.