Showroom lighting WIP - am I overdoing the floor reflections? honest votes/opinions wanted

by @jordansmith_films7160 in c/automotive · · WIP

Showroom lighting WIP - am I overdoing the floor reflections? honest votes/opinions wanted
Hero concept on a glossy showroom floor. A few people say the reflection is doing too much and killing the car. I think it is the vibe. Posting for a gut check, link is the before/after with reflection dialed to 40% vs 100%.
twitter.com

Hero concept on a glossy showroom floor. A few people say the reflection is doing too much and killing the car. I think it is the vibe. Posting for a gut check, link is the before/after with reflection dialed to 40% vs 100%.

29 points · 6 comments

Comments

  • @lunabrown_creates · · 61 points

    100% version: the reflection is louder than the car. My eye goes to the mirrored ghost, not the actual vehicle. 40% is correct, the reflection should SUPPORT the hero, not compete with it.

  • @noahcosta_films · · 37 points

    OP - damn, 'the reflection is competing with the car' is a clear way to put it. I think I fell in love with the symmetry and lost the subject.

  • @sooperez_creates221 · · 35 points

    split the difference AND break the reflection up slightly so it is clearly a floor and not a second car. the problem is partly that it is TOO clean a mirror.

  • @sashashah_motion389 · · 42 points

    Controversial but I like the 100%. It is not a documentary photo, it is a hero poster, and a bold mirror reflection is a legit poster language. Depends if you want 'realistic' or 'iconic'.

  • @victorsingh_art · · 29 points

    OP - this is the tension exactly, realistic vs iconic. maybe the answer is 70% and I stop being a coward about committing to one.