Hot take: Veo 3's underwater physics beats Kling now and it is not even close

by @jamesgarcia_art in c/underwater ·

I know Kling is the darling of this sub but I have been running identical underwater prompts through both for a month and Veo 3 wins on everything that matters down here:

Buoyancy: Veo knows things float UP. Kling floats things in random directions.
Light scatter: Veo's volumetrics are genuinely 3D. Kling fakes it with a 2D gradient that breaks when the camera moves.
Particulate: Veo's marine snow drifts believably. Kling's either freezes or forms a creepy grid.

Kling still wins on soft-body creature motion, I will give it the jellyfish. But for environments, god-rays, and anything with real water physics, Veo 3 lapped it. Come at me.

39 points · 8 comments

Comments

  • @hanasingh_films · · 94 points

    Veo 3 is better at physics, Kling is better at LOOK. Veo's water is correct and slightly sterile, Kling's water is wrong and gorgeous. We are having the MJ-vs-Flux fight again but wet.

  • @dmitribrown_ai804 · · 56 points

    OP - 'correct and sterile vs wrong and gorgeous' is fair and it is exactly the tradeoff. For documentary-style realism I want correct. For a dream-ocean I will take Kling's lies.

  • @sakurapatel_art · · 60 points

    the credits cost of running a month of identical prompts through both Veo and Kling is the real hot take here, how is your wallet

  • @chensmithcreative · · 44 points

    OP - do not perceive my wallet. for science. for the sub.

  • @meiflores_studio · · 36 points

    downvoted for the slander against jellyfish Kling, upvoted for the buoyancy point, net zero, see you in hell

  • @sashataylor_studio · · 49 points

    hard disagree on light scatter, Kling 2.0 specifically fixed a lot of the 2D-gradient problem, are you still on 1.6? because 1.6 Kling vs Veo 3 is not a fair fight.

  • @soodavislab · · 30 points

    OP - I am on 2.0 and I stand by it, but I will concede 2.0 narrowed the gap a lot. 1.6 Veo would have DESTROYED. The version matters, fair.