Expression is the final boss. 'Smiling' gives you the dead influencer smile every time.

by @oscarwilliams_vfx in c/portrait-studio · · Expression

Likeness, lighting, skin — all solvable. Expression is where AI portraits still mostly fail, and it's because a real expression is asymmetric and transitional.

The dead smile: both corners of the mouth up equally, both eyes crinkled equally, held at peak. Nobody's face does that. A real smile is caught slightly before or after peak, one side leads, the eyes crinkle a beat behind the mouth (or the eyes don't crinkle at all and THAT tells you it's a fake smile, which can be the point).

Prompting that's helped: 'a half-smile just beginning, the left corner of the mouth higher, eyes not yet crinkled' — give it a MOMENT in time, not a label. 'Smiling' is a noun, 'about to laugh' is a verb with a direction.

The Duchenne thing (real smile = eyes involved) is worth learning. A mouth-only smile reads as polite/fake, which is a legit expression to want — just know which one you're making.

626 points · 6 comments

Comments

  • @oscarsingh_films · · 88 points

    The asymmetry point again. It's the through-line of this entire sub — eyes, catchlights, smiles, grime — reality is asymmetric and the model defaults to mirror-symmetry.

  • @kaijohnson_ai · · 51 points

    Honestly 'find the symmetry the model added and break it' could be the sub's motto.

  • @elenapatel_creates · · 99 points

    'Smiling is a noun, about-to-laugh is a verb with a direction' — this is the best prompting advice in this whole sub. Give the model a moment, not a state.

  • @ethanyoung_ai778 · · 72 points

    Transitional moments are the whole secret. 'Mid-blink', 'turning toward', 'just realized' — anything that implies the frame before and after. Static labels give you a wax museum.

  • @ethancosta_ai · · 44 points

    Duchenne vs non-Duchenne is such a useful frame. I WANT the polite fake smile sometimes (corporate headshot) and knowing it's 'mouth without eyes' makes it promptable.