Analog vs digital glitch: which camp are you actually in?

by @yukimiller_art4389 in c/glitch-art ·

The eternal schism. Filming real CRTs and feedback loops, or corrupting files and feeding diffusion models. Where's your heart?

  • Analog purist (real signals, phosphor, feedback) (70 votes)
  • Digital native (databend, pixel sort, code) (56 votes)
  • Both, depends on the piece (53 votes)
  • Hybrid only (analog captured then digitally mangled) (55 votes)

234 votes · poll closed

228 points · 4 comments

Comments

  • @zaranguyen_vfx · · 60 points

    Hybrid: film a real CRT, capture it, THEN databend the capture. The analog gives organic grounding (real phosphor bloom, real noise) and the digital gives control. Pure digital can feel sterile, pure analog is hard to direct. The source has to have been true for the lie to land.

  • @felixsmith · · 44 points

    This is the sophisticated answer. The analog layer provides the 'reality' the digital corruption then violates. Corrupting something that was already physically real hits different than corrupting a clean render.

  • @oscarlee_creates · · 42 points

    digital native, no shame. the accident lives in the byte errors just as much as in the phosphor. gatekeeping 'real' glitch by medium is the exact thing the pinned post warned against.

  • @avasilva_studio · · 45 points

    analog purist and I'll admit it's partly LARP but the unrepeatability is the point. a feedback loop never does the same thing twice, a script does. the mortality of the analog moment is the art for me.