Be honest about what this sub actually wants: high fantasy wonder or grimdark misery?

by @williamgupta_digital494 in c/fantasy-worlds · · Lore

Soaring elven cities and noble dragons, or mud, blood, and everyone dies? The flair split suggests we're divided. Where's the sub's true heart?

  • High fantasy, give me wonder and beauty (28 votes)
  • Grimdark, the world is cruel and I'm here for it (38 votes)
  • Low fantasy, grounded, magic is rare and scary (36 votes)
  • Noblebright (dark world, but hope matters) (37 votes)
  • Whatever has the best worldbuilding, tone is secondary (28 votes)

167 votes · poll closed

47 points · 9 comments

Comments

  • @emmapark_films · · 79 points

    'whatever has the best worldbuilding, tone is secondary' is the galaxy-brained correct answer, a deeply-realized high fantasy beats a shallow grimdark and vice versa, COHERENCE is the actual value, grimdark is just an aesthetic some people hide thin worldbuilding behind

  • @oliviasantos_art · · 57 points

    grimdark as a mask for lazy worldbuilding is a real phenomenon, 'it's dark and everyone's awful' is used to skip the hard work of making a world that FUNCTIONS, misery is not depth, a cruel world still needs an economy

  • @natashachopralab · · 51 points

    noblebright is the underrated correct answer, a dark world where hope and decency STILL MATTER and cost something is more powerful than either pure wonder (no stakes) or pure misery (no point), the light matters because of the dark

  • @leojohnson_vfx · · 36 points

    noblebright > grimdark because despair is easy and hope-against-the-dark is hard, a world that earns its hope is doing more work than a world that just wallows

  • @taylorsmithcreative341 · · 45 points

    high fantasy is having a comeback honestly, we did a decade of everything-is-mud and people are starving for WONDER again, for an elven city that makes you gasp instead of a dung-heap that makes you grimace

  • @felixbrown_vfx · · 33 points

    the grimdark fatigue is real, I want to feel AWE again, I've seen enough mud, show me something beautiful enough to believe in