My AI actors can't do comedic timing. Blink delay? Pause length? Teach me the micro-stuff.

by @nikolaibrown_creates in c/comedy-sketches · · Feedback Wanted

Newish and stuck on the thing everyone says is the hard part: timing. My jokes are written fine (I think) but the AI delivery flattens them. The actors rush, they don't hold, they don't react.

Specific questions:
How long is a comedic 'hold' before a punchline, in frames? Is there a rule of thumb?
Do you add the pause in the PROMPT or create it in the EDIT by holding the frame?
Any trick for a reaction beat, cutting to a deadpan face AFTER the joke?

I keep reading 'work the pause' but nobody says HOW. Give me the actual mechanics please.

355 points · 6 comments

Comments

  • @oliviakimcreative4594 · · 100 points

    Here's the actual mechanics you asked for: 1) The pause is in the EDIT, not the prompt. The model won't hold reliably, so you hold the frame or add a cutaway. 2) Rule of thumb: the beat before a punchline is ~12-18 frames (half a second-ish) of stillness. The beat AFTER, before you cut, is similar. 3) Reaction beat: generate a SEPARATE deadpan face clip and cut to it for ~20 frames after the punchline. The audience laughs at the reaction, not the line.

  • @ethanchenworks · · 100 points

    The 'pause is in the edit, not the prompt' is THE lesson. Stop trying to get the model to time, it can't. YOU time it in post. The model gives you clay, you sculpt the rhythm. Comedic timing is an editing skill in this medium, full stop.

  • @hanasilva_creates7829 · · 86 points

    For the reaction beat specifically: it doesn't even have to be a character IN the scene. Cut to a dog looking unimpressed. Cut to a houseplant. The 'reaction' just needs to be something the audience can project their own 'what' onto. Deadpan anything works.

  • @oliviakim_digital · · 72 points

    The thing nobody tells beginners: your jokes being 'written fine' and still flattening is NORMAL and it's an editing problem, not a writing problem. Don't rewrite the joke. Re-time it. 90% of 'my joke isn't landing' is a rhythm issue in the cut.