Got a hand to reach down through the clouds and lift a city bus off the highway, settings inside

by @raviparkcreative1089 in c/surrealist · · Impossible Scale

Scale test I'm finally happy with. A hand the size of a mountain range comes down through cloud cover and picks a single bus off a highway like a toy.

Three things that made it work:
Generate the hand and the landscape as ONE still, never comped. Models composite scale badly and nail it when it's native.
Make the clouds part AROUND the wrist. That occlusion is what sells the size.
Keep the bus sharp and tiny. If the bus blurs, your brain loses the ruler and the whole illusion folds.

Flux for the plate, Kling for the descent. Seed 772301, motion 0.4, 'slow deliberate reach, clouds displacing around the wrist, highway in sharp focus below.' Full prompt in a reply.

435 points · 6 comments

Comments

  • @elenajackson_vfx · · 73 points

    'if the bus blurs your brain loses the ruler' should be a sticky. that's the whole trick to scale and nobody says it

  • @jameshoffmannpro · · 41 points

    i learned it the hard way after 30 blurry buses. the sharp tiny object is non-negotiable.

  • @chenchencreative · · 28 points

    the clouds parting around the wrist is the kind of detail that separates a scale shot from a sticker on a sky. nice

  • @meiwilson_motion · · 33 points

    tried native plate vs comp and it's not even close, native wins every time, the shadow and haze just agree with each other

  • @avawatanabe_digital604 · · 12 points

    motion 0.4 feels low, does it not stall? mine barely moves at 0.4

  • @victortanaka_creates · · 19 points

    low motion plus a very explicit motion phrase. the number caps it, the words aim it. high motion on a scale shot gives you jelly.