My elf character finally doesn't look like a generic pretty person with pointy ears, here's how

by @avasmith859 in c/fantasy-worlds · · Character

The AI elf problem: prompt 'elf' and you get an extremely symmetrical conventionally-attractive human with pointed ears bolted on. There's no ELF there, no sense of a different PEOPLE, just a model with elf-cosplay accessories. I wanted an elf that felt genuinely non-human, old, other.

What worked was leaning into SUBTLE wrongness rather than just 'pretty + ears':
proportions: 'slightly too-long neck and fingers, a face a fraction too narrow, large eyes set a touch too wide' — tiny deviations from human proportion read as 'another species' not 'ugly'
AGE without aging: 'ageless, unlined skin but ancient weary eyes, the face of someone who has seen a thousand years' — the mismatch of young skin and old eyes is deeply uncanny in the right way
stillness: 'preternaturally still, composed, as if time means nothing to them' in the pose

The 'young skin, ancient eyes' combination is the whole thing. It's the uncanny that makes elves ELVEN, not their ears. They're beautiful the way a glacier is beautiful, not the way a model is. Character in comments, she looks like she'd find your whole lifespan quaint.

526 points · 8 comments

Comments

  • @leomartin · · 96 points

    'young skin, ancient weary eyes' is the single best elf-design insight I've ever read, the OTHERNESS of an elf isn't the ears, it's the TIME behind the eyes, a being that's beautiful and unlined but has watched your great-great-grandparents be born and die, the mismatch is the magic

  • @leomartinezlab · · 64 points

    the subtle-proportion-deviation trick is the other half and it's so smart, 'pretty human + ears' is cosplay, 'human-but-the-proportions-are-a-fraction-off' triggers the subconscious 'that's not quite one of us' response, uncanny valley used ON PURPOSE for the right effect

  • @quinnking300 · · 58 points

    'beautiful the way a glacier is beautiful, not the way a model is' is a gorgeous line and also a genuine design directive, glacier-beauty is cold, vast, slow, indifferent, inhuman, that's the elven register, not 'hot person,' you nailed the VIBE in a sentence

  • @victormiller_films · · 41 points

    the distinction between model-beauty (warm, inviting, FOR you) and glacier-beauty (cold, indifferent, NOT for you) is exactly how to make a beautiful non-human that doesn't just read as 'attractive human,' the beauty has to be ALIENATING

  • @jordanmueller_films9965 · · 44 points

    'she looks like she'd find your whole lifespan quaint' is the character in one sentence, you can feel the condescension of deep time, she's not mean, she just operates on a scale where your whole life is an afternoon, that's SO elf