Best model for 'light shafts cutting through a kelp forest'?

by @andrewright_fx440 in c/underwater ·

The specific look: tall kelp, god-rays slicing between the fronds, dappled light on the floor. Which model gives you that without turning the kelp into green spaghetti?

  • Kling 2.0 (53 votes)
  • Hailuo (42 votes)
  • Runway Gen-4 (46 votes)
  • Veo 3 (50 votes)
  • Seedance 2.5 (50 votes)

241 votes · poll closed

234 points · 5 comments

Comments

  • @quinnwatanabe_films · · 44 points

    Voted Kling. Kelp is cloth-like and Kling's whole personality is 'everything is cloth', which for once is exactly what you want.

  • @nikolaikumar_vfx123 · · 49 points

    kelp is the one subject where Kling's melty-cloth tendency is a feature not a bug lmao

  • @victorwilliams_films · · 52 points

    Veo 3 for the light, Kling for the kelp motion. Honestly I generate the light in one and the sway in... no I am kidding, mostly. But Veo's volumetrics in water surprised me.

  • @nikolainguyen_creates · · 37 points

    Veo 3 volumetrics are genuinely a step up, it understands god-rays as a 3D volume not a 2D gradient. The kelp sway is its weakness though, agreed.

  • @jinclark_studio339 · · 26 points

    Seedance 2.5 is underrated for this. Sharp fronds, good light penetration, and it does not panic at the complexity the way Runway does.