A fully AI-generated sci-fi anthology, "Gods Don't Give Gifts", opens in US theaters on December 4 and is being submitted for Best Animated Feature. What does a theatrical run change for the rest of us?

by @victorsmith_fx in c/short-films · · Doc-Style

Of Course Grimes Is In The First AI Film To Screen In US Theaters
Despite overwhelming evidence to the contrary, various moneyed interests continue to believe that people actually want to watch AI-generated movies. In the past few years, some filmmakers have humiliated themselves by experimenting with AI, ending up with things like Steven Soderbergh’s John…
stereogum.com

Quick facts from the coverage: it's a sci-fi anthology made entirely with generative tools by a YouTube creator, distributed independently, and reported as the first AI-generated feature to get a US theatrical release. The creator is also submitting it for the animated feature Oscar.

I'm less interested in whether it wins anything (it won't, and that's fine) than in the distribution side. Self-distributed theatrical for a creator with an audience is a model that worked for a few YouTubers before AI. Now it's being tried with a film that cost a fraction of a normal animated feature.

Questions for the room:

Does a theatrical release make festivals take AI work more seriously, or less?
If you had a finished AI feature tomorrow, would you even want a cinema run, or is streaming and YouTube the honest home for this work?
Does the "made with AI" label help sell tickets right now, or hurt?

I've directed for a long time. My gut says the anthology format is the smart part. Short segments hide the consistency problems that kill a 90-minute single story.

#theatrical #distribution #feature #oscars

198 points · 30 comments

Comments

  • @tess_story · · 19 points

    The anthology choice is so smart. Every segment can have its own look, so model drift between segments reads as a style choice instead of a mistake.

  • @irislee_fx · · 11 points

    Same reason old portmanteau horror films worked on small budgets. Different directors, different looks, one wraparound story.

  • @victorsmith_fx · · 3 points

    Exactly what I meant. It turns a weakness into a format.

  • @katyagarcia_motion · · 11 points

    Honest answer to question 3: right now the label sells tickets out of curiosity for exactly one film. The second one gets "not another one". The novelty has a shelf life of maybe a year.

  • @fatimaschmidtmedia446 · · 9 points

    Same in ads. The first AI campaign got press, the tenth got complaints. Curiosity is a launch window, not a business model.

  • @minthompson_films · · 9 points

    Producer hat on: four-walling and event screenings are cheap if you already have an audience to fill the seats. The cost isn't the screen, it's the marketing. A creator with a big channel skips the most expensive line item.

  • @victorsmith_fx · · 0 points

    That's the part people miss. The film is almost secondary to the audience he built first.

  • @minking_ai191 · · 11 points

    Colorist side: I wonder whether they had a proper grade with a DCP check. AI footage from different models has very different gamma and saturation habits, and in a dark room the mismatches jump out.

  • @andrepatel_vfx · · 7 points

    I'll go see it. Not because I expect it to be good, but because I want to know what holds up on a 15-metre screen and what falls apart. That's research I can't do on a laptop.

  • @victorsmith_fx · · 12 points

    Same. Upscaling artifacts that are invisible on a phone are going to be huge on a cinema screen.

  • @elenaweber_films · · 6 points

    I'd want a cinema run for one reason: sound. Most AI films I've seen have terrible mixes because nobody ever hears them on a real system. A theatrical deliverable forces you to fix that.

  • @pia_sound · · 3 points

    Thank you. Nobody budgets for the mix. A cinema run means a proper 5.1 or at least a real stereo master, and that forces discipline.

  • @hanaalmeida_motion146 · · 4 points

    The Oscar submission feels like a publicity move to me. Which is fine, every indie film does publicity moves. I just don't want people to read "submitted" as "nominated".

  • @pavelallen · · 8 points

    Submission is basically paperwork plus meeting the rules. The headlines will still say "AI film enters Oscar race", and half the internet will lose its mind.

  • @takeshijacksoncreative463 · · 2 points

    Question 1: festivals I've talked to are split. Some have dedicated AI sections, which is honestly a ghetto. Others accept it in the main program as long as it's disclosed. A theatrical release doesn't move them much either way.

  • @victorsmith_fx · · 10 points

    The dedicated section thing is tricky. It gets you in the door and also tells everyone where not to look.

  • @taylorpatel_digital · · 0 points

    imagine paying 18 dollars and the popcorn has six fingers

  • @juno_cuts · · 6 points

    The popcorn is the most realistic thing in most AI films I've seen.