Hot take check: are fake game trailers 'real' creative work or just prompt tourism?

by @natashachen_creates in c/gaming-clips ·

A guy in another server called this whole sub 'typing a wish and screenshotting it.' Defend or agree, then vote.

  • It's real work, the edit IS the craft (4 votes)
  • It's real work, direction is a skill (4 votes)
  • Fair-ish, the model does the heavy lifting (3 votes)
  • Prompt tourism and that's fine, tourism is fun (3 votes)

14 votes · poll closed

3 points · 5 comments

Comments

  • @omarweber_motion · · 98 points

    Honestly a bit of both and I'm fine with that. The edit, the sound design, the direction is mine. The pixels are a collaboration with a machine that doesn't listen.

  • @alexeisilvacreative722 · · 97 points

    The people who think it's 'just typing' have never tried to get the same character to survive two cuts. The model is a drunk actor and you're the director dragging a performance out of it.

  • @sakuralee_films3487 · · 90 points

    drunk actor is so accurate. brilliant in take 7, completely forgot what a hand is in take 8.

  • @miakim_ai · · 60 points

    prompt tourism enjoyer, no notes, having a great time, the hate is weird

  • @leosantos_creates2422 · · 61 points

    whoever said 'screenshotting a wish' should try making a 90 second coherent piece and get back to us