Hot take: most 'abstract' art here is people hiding weak prompts behind blur and calling it depth

by @sashamartinez_studio in c/abstract-art ·

Going to be unpopular but someone has to say it. A large fraction of what gets posted as 'abstract' is not a deliberate reduction to form, it's a FAILED representational prompt that got blurred/glitched until you couldn't tell it failed, then relabeled 'abstract' to dodge critique.

Real abstraction is HARDER than representation, not easier. With a figure, the model does the heavy lifting and you judge likeness. With pure form, there's NOTHING to hide behind, every compositional decision is exposed, and weak composition has no subject to distract from it. So a LOT of people use 'abstract' as a shield, if there's no subject, there's no 'wrong', so no one can say it failed, right? Wrong. It just means it failed at the only thing it had, composition.

You can tell the real abstractionists (the color-field crit folks, the generative-system people, the geometric-tension studies) from the hiders (blurry mush, 'ethereal' as the only descriptor, a suspicious amount of fog). Blur is not depth. Vagueness is not mystery. Fog is not abstraction. If you can't defend your composition, adding more blur won't save it.

87 points · 8 comments

Comments

  • @victorsantos_creates · · 91 points

    As someone whose last three 'abstract' posts were, if I'm honest, exactly the 'failed representation + blur + ethereal' pattern you're describing: ow. But also, fair. I knew the fog was doing the hiding. I'm going to go study actual composition now. The hot take is mean but it found its target. Me. It found me specifically.

  • @liamwilliams_creates · · 58 points

    This self-aware reply is worth more than the whole hot take. The fog-hiding thing is a real trap and recognizing it in your own work is the first step out. Go look at Diebenkorn and Kelly for composition, and come back and post something you can DEFEND. We'll be here. Growth over fog.

  • @noahtanaka_ai4340 · · 97 points

    Counterpoint on the craft itself: blur and fog CAN be legitimate abstract tools, atmospheric abstraction, softness as a deliberate quality (think Turner's late work, basically abstract). The problem isn't blur, it's UNINTENTIONAL blur masking indecision. Deliberate softness with compositional intent is great. Accidental softness hiding no-intent is the actual target. Don't throw out soft abstraction, throw out thoughtless softness.

  • @evelynlimaworks872 · · 71 points

    The Turner point is important, softness is not the enemy, THOUGHTLESS softness is. Some of the most profound abstraction is atmospheric and soft-edged. The tell isn't 'is it blurry', it's 'is the blur DOING something or HIDING something'. A hard distinction between 'blur bad / sharp good' would be its own kind of philistinism. Intent is the variable, not edge quality.

  • @yunalopezcreative · · 95 points

    You're mostly right and being a bit of a jerk about it, which is the house style for these 'hot take' posts I guess. The real, useful core: abstraction has NOTHING to hide behind, so weak composition is fully exposed, and blur is often used to disguise a lack of compositional intent. True. But 'they're all hiding failed prompts' is uncharitable, some people are genuinely exploring and learning, and gatekeeping 'real abstractionist' vs 'hider' is exactly the kind of purity-policing that makes subs insufferable.

  • @noahscott899 · · 98 points

    The defensible thesis is 'blur isn't automatically depth, and vague isn't automatically profound'. The indefensible part is assuming everyone posting soft work is CYNICALLY hiding. Plenty of people posting mush are sincerely bad at composition and WANT to improve, that's not hiding, that's learning in public. Aim the critique at the WORK, not the imagined motives of the makers.