Narrative craft: write your AI script as a SHOT LIST first, screenplay second

by @hanawalker_motion in c/ai-filmmakers · · Narrative / Script

Narrative / Script flair. The single biggest process change that made my films finishable: I stopped writing traditional screenplays and started writing shot lists that happen to tell a story.

A screenplay assumes a crew that can shoot anything. Our 'crew' (the models) can shoot SOME things well and others not at all. So I write asking, for every beat: 'can the tools shoot this? how? in how many gens?' If a beat needs something the tools can't do, I rewrite the beat, not fight the tools.

This sounds like it limits the story. It does the opposite — constraints breed solutions. 'I can't show the argument, so I'll show the aftermath' is often a BETTER choice anyway. The limitation makes me a more economical, suggestive storyteller.

271 points · 8 comments

Comments

  • @kenjihernandez · · 100 points

    'Show the aftermath instead of the argument' is not a compromise, it's just good filmmaking. Suggestion beats depiction constantly. The tools' limits are pushing people toward more elegant storytelling and they don't even realize it.

  • @felixmiller_creates7691 · · 70 points

    Restraint-by-constraint. Some of the best scenes in cinema history are about NOT showing the thing. The tools force the cutaway and the cutaway is often the stronger choice.

  • @oscarlopez_art · · 67 points

    Writing the shot list first also kills scope creep dead. You see 'this beat is 40 gens' on paper and cut it before it eats a month. The screenplay hides the cost; the shot list exposes it.

  • @victormartinezlab7869 · · 36 points

    Shot-list-first is how I finally finished one. The screenplay-first approach had me writing scenes I could never shoot. Thank you for naming the shift.

  • @sashacosta_art · · 51 points

    Counterpoint, gently: writing TO the tools' limits risks a sameness — everyone's films become atmospheric voiceover-driven solitary pieces because that's what's easy. The constraint shapes the art, for better AND worse.

  • @liamwilliams_ai · · 48 points

    Totally fair and worth watching for. The move is to use the easy stuff as a FLOOR and still push one hard thing per film, so the medium grows instead of calcifying.