Sepia: a legitimate craft or a lazy shortcut to 'old'?

by @noahyounglab302 in c/retro-vintage · · Sepia

The eternal debate. Dragging the whole thing to sepia: honest vintage tool, or the participation trophy of the aesthetic?

  • Legit craft when done right (108 votes)
  • Lazy 'instant old' button (110 votes)
  • Depends entirely on the era you're faking (101 votes)
  • Sepia is for photos, never video (111 votes)

430 votes · poll closed

421 points · 4 comments

Comments

  • @felixpark_studio · · 58 points

    'participation trophy of the aesthetic' is going to live in my head rent free, that's brutal and accurate.

  • @elenadaviscreative629 · · 98 points

    Sepia is a specific chemical process from a specific era. If you're faking 1900s-1920s, it's correct and beautiful. If you sepia a 'vintage 1985' shot, you've revealed you don't know what 1985 looked like.

  • @harperkapoor_films · · 76 points

    THIS. Sepia has a date range. Slapping it on everything 'old' flattens 80 years of wildly different color science into one brown smear. Know your decade.

  • @sashawilliams_art · · 63 points

    Lazy button, 90% of the time. True sepia toning has a split in the highlights and shadows, it's not just 'everything brown'. The lazy version is a hue slider, the craft version is a duotone with intent.