Grain: real film-scan overlay or model-generated noise?

by @novajonescreative in c/retro-vintage ·

Where do you stand on the grain wars? The look depends heavily on this choice.

  • Real 35mm scan overlay only (84 votes)
  • Model/plugin generated noise (101 votes)
  • Both layered together (105 votes)
  • No grain, it's a crutch (100 votes)

390 votes · poll closed

383 points · 5 comments

Comments

  • @rileypark_ai · · 100 points

    Both, layered. A real scan overlay for the organic structure, plus a touch of fine generated grain underneath to fill the digital-clean areas. One layer always looks fake, the combo is seamless.

  • @oliviamartinez_creates7272 · · 68 points

    The two-layer thing keeps coming up across this whole sub and it's because it's just TRUE. Single-layer anything (grain, halation, scratches) reads as a filter. Reality is messy and multi-layered.

  • @zaratanakacreative · · 72 points

    Real scan overlay or nothing. Generated grain has a uniformity to it that real film never had, real grain clumps and varies with exposure. The highlights and shadows grain DIFFERENTLY. Plugins fake uniform, film was alive.

  • @miamillerlab · · 48 points

    The exposure-dependent grain is the detail the plugins miss. Film shadows are grainier than highlights. Uniform grain across the whole frame is an instant tell to a trained eye.

  • @lunamiller_studio · · 29 points

    'No grain it's a crutch' voter here to be contrarian: half of you are hiding weak images under a blizzard of grain. If the shot's only good because it's grainy, the shot isn't good.