The enso: one breath, one circle, and the model gives me a perfect donut every time (which is wrong)

by @ravisilvaworks693 in c/ink-wash · · Minimal / One-Stroke

The enso (the zen circle) is supposed to be ONE breath, ONE stroke - thick where you start, thinning as the brush empties, often open (not closed), the irregularity recording the single gesture and the state of mind. A PERFECT circle is a failed enso. The imperfection is the entire meaning.

The model gives me gorgeous, even, closed, perfect circles - which is exactly wrong. I have to prompt HARD for 'single brushstroke circle, open gap, irregular, thinning dry-brush where the brush empties, imperfect, one gesture' and even then it tends toward too-even. The model can't help being good at circles, and the enso needs it to be human-bad.

131 points · 7 comments

Comments

  • @caseyrodriguezworks · · 100 points

    'the model can't help being good at circles and the enso needs it to be human-bad' - this is the single funniest and truest sentence about AI sumi-e. the enso is the ultimate test because here PERFECTION is the failure state.

  • @sashagarcia_studio · · 95 points

    the OPEN enso especially. the gap where the brush left the paper is the breath ending. a closed perfect circle has no breath in it, no beginning or end. the model closes it because closed = 'complete' in its training.

  • @oliviagarcia_studio · · 70 points

    the dry-brush thinning as the brush empties is the record of the single continuous gesture. if the line is even all the way around, there was no single gesture, it was 'drawn.' the taper is the proof of life.

  • @jasminethompson_creates441 · · 55 points

    genuinely the enso is where I gave up on pure prompt and just... paint them for real now. it's one stroke. I can do one stroke. the model makes it harder than my own hand.

  • @miameyer_motion410 · · 48 points

    the ultimate irony: the SIMPLEST sumi-e subject is the one where doing it yourself is easier than prompting it. one breath, one circle. the model overthinks a thing that's supposed to be thoughtless.