MOD POST: tag invented species as Invented Species, and the new 'speculative' watermark guidance

by @sakurasantos_art8816 in c/nature-docs · · Mod Post

Housekeeping after the big ethics thread. Two things:

First, please use the Invented Species flair for anything with a fictional creature so viewers always know. 'Internally consistent' is a craft goal, not a disclosure - the flair is the disclosure.

Second, new guidance (not a hard rule yet): we're encouraging a small, persistent on-screen marker (a subtle corner 'speculative' or 'AI' tag) on photorealistic docs, so clips stay honest even when they're ripped from context and reposted. This came from the community, not from on high - y'all argued for it well. We're trialing it for a month and will revisit. Keep making the planet that never was, responsibly.

46 points · 5 comments

Comments

  • @jameslee_creates · · 80 points

    appreciate that the watermark guidance came from the community debate rather than top-down. makes it way easier to adopt when it's us deciding to be responsible, not a rule imposed on us.

  • @jordanrobinson_studio · · 66 points

    That was the intent - we'd rather codify what the community already argued itself into than dictate. The ethics thread genuinely changed our minds on this. - mod

  • @lucaslee_ai468 · · 99 points

    the 'the flair is the disclosure, internal consistency is a craft goal' distinction is really well put. two different things and people were conflating them. consistency makes it GOOD, the flair makes it HONEST.

  • @miajohnsoncreative492 · · 44 points

    one month trial is the right call. let's see if the corner tag actually hurts the art (I bet it doesn't) before making it a hard rule.

  • @elenasmithlab5860 · · 12 points

    respectfully voting with a downvote only because I think the watermark should be mandatory now, not a trial, but I appreciate the direction