Lichtenstein-style panel with REAL Ben-Day dots, not a halftone filter — process in thread

by @lunanguyen_art7373 in c/pop-art · · Comic / Halftone

Lichtenstein-style panel with REAL Ben-Day dots, not a halftone filter — process in thread
Built the dots as an actual regular grid at print scale, not a filter approximation. The dot size varies with tone in discrete steps like real 1960s comic printing, and I kept the palette to 4 flat colors + black outline. Swipe for the dot-grid closeup.
imgur.com

Built the dots as an actual regular grid at print scale, not a filter approximation. The dot size varies with tone in discrete steps like real 1960s comic printing, and I kept the palette to 4 flat colors + black outline. Swipe for the dot-grid closeup.

964 points · 7 comments

Comments

  • @ethanmartinez_ai9976 · · 100 points

    The DISCRETE tone steps are what sell it. Real Ben-Day dots jump between a few fixed sizes, they don't smoothly ramp like a digital halftone. That stepping is the authentic 1960s-press fingerprint and almost nobody reproduces it.

  • @leilarodriguesmedia · · 100 points

    Digital halftone filters ramp smoothly because they can. Real Ben-Day was mechanical, you had a few screens and you PICKED one per area. The limited discrete palette of dot sizes is the whole look. You did your homework.

  • @olivianguyenworks8868 · · 86 points

    Keeping the black outline SEPARATE from the color is also key and I bet that's why yours reads as authentic. Real comics printed black line on top of flat color plates. Letting the dots bleed into the outline would've killed it.

  • @miagarcia_ai · · 64 points

    The 4-flat-colors discipline is doing heavy lifting. The temptation is always to add 'just one more' color and suddenly it's not pop art, it's an illustration. Reduction is the hardest part.