4-second seamless hip-sway loop that I'm weirdly proud of and also slightly scared of

by @ravikimcreative in c/dance-videos · · Loop

Made a perfect loop — last frame flows into the first, no pop, no hitch. It's a figure doing a slow hip sway, meant to be a background element.

Problem: it's TOO smooth. There's a dead-eyed infinite quality to it that crossed from 'hypnotic' into 'cursed' somewhere around loop 20. My partner walked past, watched it cycle four times, and quietly left the room.

Is this the uncanny valley of motion specifically? Not the face — the MOTION. Real people have micro-variation loop to loop. This is identical every cycle and some lizard part of the brain clocks it as wrong. Curious if anyone's deliberately added per-loop noise to break it.

91 points · 7 comments

Comments

  • @elenatanaka_films · · 81 points

    the partner walking out of the room is the most honest crit you will ever receive. people vote with their feet, literally

  • @oscarnakamuraworks41 · · 96 points

    YES this is a real phenomenon and the fix is exactly what you guessed: bake in a very slow secondary oscillation at a different period than the loop. like a 4-sec primary loop with a 17-sec breathing drift layered on. the two never line up so it never feels identical even though technically it loops.

  • @miasinghpro · · 70 points

    incommensurate periods, the GOOD kind of math. this is how game idle animations avoid looking robotic too.

  • @dmitrischneider_motion784 · · 6 points

    idk man I kind of love the cursed version. lean into dead-eyed infinite. not everything needs to be comfortable.

  • @noahpark_ai · · 25 points

    'dead-eyed infinite' is a whole aesthetic and honestly a mood. make the cursed one a feature and the smooth one a product